Asterra Estate vs Maclear
Which platform performs better in 2026? Anonymized data from real investor portfolios on P2P Dash: returns, sentiment and facts side by side.
Community data compared
As of September 18, 2026
 Asterra Estate |  Maclear | |
|---|---|---|
| Community ranking 2026 | #21 of 27 | #23 of 27 |
| Median net return (XIRR) | 23.6% | 23.4% |
| Median cash drag | 0.5% | 3.7% |
| Investors on P2P Dash | 288 | 440 |
| Combined portfolio value | €1.99M | €4.18M |
| Interest earned all-time | €201K | €586K |
Platform facts
| Founded | 2025 | 2023 |
| Headquarters | 🇪🇪 Estonia | 🇨🇭 Switzerland |
| Regulated | No | Yes |
| Buyback Guarantee | No | No |
| Secondary Market | No | Yes |
| Auto-Invest | No | Yes |
Returns year by year
Median net return per calendar year, from the portfolios that track each platform.
Asterra Estate
18.4%
Last 12 months · All time 23.6%
46 investors
Maclear
23.2%
Last 12 months · All time 23.4%
91 investors
30.9%
20.7%
2025
18.8%
21.8%
2026
Across 2 shared years each platform led in 1.
How far apart investors land
The bar covers the middle 50% of investors, the mark is the median.
Asterra Estate Middle 50% of investors: 22.5% – 28.1%
Median net return (XIRR): 23.6%
Maclear Middle 50% of investors: 17.5% – 28.3%
Median net return (XIRR): 23.4%
Asterra Estate investors sit closer together: 5.6% between the 25th and 75th percentile, against 10.8%.
What investors plan to do next
The strategy each investor stated for the platform, from adding funds to exiting.
Asterra Estate 23% · Based on 88 stated strategies
Maclear 32% · Based on 107 stated strategies
Where the money is going
Deposits minus withdrawals per month over the last year, across the investors who track each platform.
Asterra Estate +€1,087,283
Net flow, last 12 months
+135 tracked investors over the year
Investors who track both
98 investors track both platforms.
34% of Asterra Estate investors also track Maclear.
22% of Maclear investors also track Asterra Estate.
What the data says
Both platforms currently deliver a similar median net return: 23.6% at Asterra Estate versus 23.4% at Maclear.
Investor sentiment currently favors Maclear: 32% of stated strategies are “add funds” or “reinvest”, versus 23% at Asterra Estate.
Maclear is the bigger platform on P2P Dash, with 440 investors tracking it versus 288 for Asterra Estate.
Anonymized, nightly aggregated community data from P2P Dash portfolios. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. This is not investment advice.
Frequently asked questions
Answers based on anonymized community data from P2P Dash investors.
Which delivers the higher return: Asterra Estate or Maclear?
Among P2P Dash investors, Asterra Estate currently shows the higher median net return (XIRR): 23.6% versus 23.4% (as of September 18, 2026). The middle 50% of portfolios earn 22.5% – 28.1% at Asterra Estate and 17.5% – 28.3% at Maclear.
Which has done better recently, Asterra Estate or Maclear?
Over the last 12 months Maclear shows the higher median net return: 23.2% against 18.4%. All time the figures are 23.6% for Asterra Estate and 23.4% for Maclear (as of September 18, 2026).
Where do investors put new money right now, Asterra Estate or Maclear?
As of September 18, 2026, 23% of stated strategies at Asterra Estate are “add funds” or “reinvest”, compared to 32% at Maclear.
Do investors use Asterra Estate and Maclear at the same time?
98 investors on P2P Dash track both platforms. 34% of Asterra Estate investors also have Maclear in their portfolio.
How do I compare my own returns on Asterra Estate and Maclear?
Import your transaction exports from both platforms into P2P Dash for free. You get your real net return (XIRR), cash drag and income per platform, directly comparable in one dashboard.
About this data: The figures on this page are aggregated from anonymized data that P2P Dash users import themselves, plus platform details we maintain by hand. We check both, but we cannot guarantee that they are complete or free of errors. Spotted a mistake? Write to tim@newnow.de and we will correct it.
See your own numbers side by side
Import your portfolios from both platforms for free and P2P Dash shows your real net return (XIRR), cash drag and income, per platform and combined.